The importance of purpose in research: Always start with a WHY!


Research is more difficult that it seems. It needs strong methodology and a solid mathematical knowledge. In my personal opinion, the most important aspect (and where most of marketers fail) is the main question that triggers all the research, the main WHY. Within the following article, we will try to focus in this important question in order show some ways on how to accomplish a healthy market resarch study.

By fail I don’t say that marketers don’t take this question into account, I just state that they don’t put enough time and effort on it. Within the following article I will go through some basics of research and some categories that will help the researcher to classify their problems/questions and which will trigger the different ways and methods that are commonly use to get to the famous ‘insights’. 

Always start with a WHY.

To begin every single research I always try to figure out what I am expecting of it. In other words, how would I use the results. For example, it is very different a research to solve some pricing issues that product development issues. It important to understand what we want to do before jumping into the methods of doing research. This is what is called ‘diagnostic’. There are lots of types of definitions, but I always go for simplicity so this is one once I was given within some research course

Type I: Exploratory Research

This type of research is important in order to solve managerial questions that are not very well defined. Usually are given by hunches or vague insights. They often provide the context and data for further investigation. Some question we often solve are:
  • Why are sales increasing/declining/flat? 
  • What people think of our product?
  • Do users understand our value proposal?
Some examples of Exploratory Research are Focus Groups, Internet Communities, among others.

Type II: Descriptive Research

Secondly, the descriptive type of research is recommended to understand defined problems in which we need to expand our knowledge. 
For example we may need to understand: 

  • Who are our consumers?
  • How to aggregate them?
  • How much they like our products?
  • How much better are we than a certain product of the competitors?
  • What is our Share of wallet?
  • What is our NPS?
This can be done by active data collection or passive observing behavior. The first group is based on surveys (for example with Qualtrix or Surveymonkey) and the second mainly scanner data (for example of Nielsen or Ipsos), mobile data or media planning such as radio, tv or social media.

Type III: Causal Research

Finally, the Causal Research is based primary in testing the problems in order to get to the answer of the WHY.

For example, we may want to address some of the following problems:
  • How would I increase my website conversion rate if change the order of two elements?
  • What if I offer some discount based on the location of the user? What about the segment of the user?
  • Which promotion is more efficient?
  • Are our price discounts increasing the consumers’ average ticket?  
  • Which is the best way to monetize my app?
Some important fact we need to understand Causal Research. In order to simplify we can name the following:
  • Correlation: relationship between two variables.
  • Causation: one variable producing an effect in another variable.
  • Correlation is different from Causation.
To sum up, we must follow some important rules for this type of research in order to assume causation of X and Y:
  1. Correlation: Evidence of association between X and Y
  2. Temporal antecedence: X must occur before Y
  3. No third factor driving both: Control of other possible factors
Most of this type is solved by testing. The most famous test is the A/B Test because its simplicity and actionable results. Lots of companies can help marketers to do it, in order to name some you can refer to Google, Optimezely or in case of mobile data set Leanimplum or Mixpanel.

As always, we really hope you enjoy our article. Thanks for taking the time to read!

Research Tip: How to easily spot "Real effect" of variable changes vs "Mix changing effect"



In the following article, we will be reviewing some techniques to analyze and present data. These are very suitable for explaining compound metrics when the mix of single elements is taken into account. Especially, when those are defined by a weighted average using the Share of Market to ponderate.

How to compound metrics based on Share of Market?

In order to compound metrics that reflects better the effect of the single elements, we could use the weighted average instead of the simple average. For example, if we want to calculate Purchase Intention for The Coca Cola Company (as manufacturer), initially we have two possibilities:
In the simple average calculation, we don't take into account the weight of single brands and we bias the entire metric. If we take into account some weight, the metric will be healthier in terms of reflecting the reality. It is not mandatory to use the Share of Market, but we will use it just as an example since the idea is to show how to separete this effect when measuring changes of variables within different periods.
With "Fi" being the value of the Purchase Intention for the "i" brand itself, and "Si" the correspondent amount of Sales from the period.
For more information about the Weighted Average, please refer to the following link

How changes in Mix can impact on variables variations?

As observed in the following example, the average can change due to variations in the mix of Sales (weighting variable)
The increase of sales of Coca Cola boost the metric since this is the brand with the best Purchase Intention. This is a bit tricky since there is not any change of each of the brand from the company. As conclusion, if we are not careful this can lead us to think that Coca Cola Company is increasing it Purchase Intention,

How to separate the change of the variable from the effect from mix?

After the previous introduction, we now are ready to dive in the main paragraph of the article. The idea is to spot the real effect. By real, I mean the pure effect (or so) of the variable, separating and measuring the mix effect. In order to do that, we need to order the spreadsheet in the following way:

To fill the grey shaded cells we use the following formulas:


To complete the example, here are some possible insights and conclusions about the methodology (not on the data, remember it is fake data).

  • In order to check the variation, both must sum up the same
  • The same analysis of brands/manufacturer can be done with manufacturers/market
  • The 0% of mix effect does means that this brand has evolved in the same rate than the market


As always, we really hope you enjoy our article. Thanks for taking the time to read!

Internal Dialogue: How Unconscious Mind talks with our Conscious.

Did you know that most of our talking is with ourselves? Did you know the importance as marketers of targeting consumer’s unconscious mind?

In this post I am going to review in a much more comprehensive and practical way some ideas of unconscious marketing from Guerrilla Marketing – Jay Conrad Levinson.

Unconscious Mind (UM) vs Conscious Mind (CM)

According to this author, our behavior is divided into Conscious and Unconscious Decision Making Processes. The UM is in charge of so much more information and decisions than the CM. When the CM can process at the most four or five things the UM can analyze and process millions of situations and decisions. The most common situation is the UM not telling the CM all the outputs of his decisions in order to avoid an overload of the CM. Imagine that it would be impossible to live if you have to pay attention to breath, to blink, to salivate or even to beat your heart.  
But don’t think that our Conscious Mind is unnecessary or even stupid because in most cases (not every case) CM override the UM decisions.  
But we are not here to talk of every system in separated. We must understand how they connect. The main idea is what Jay calls the Internal Dialogue. This is how our UM tries to talk to the CM. I mean, all the times we make our Unconscious Value Equation, when we analyze common situations, or even when we have the famous ‘hunch’ or “Gut Feeling”.

UM is in charge of the Internal Dialogue

The voices we hear in our head are totally normal, and do not mean we have schizophrenia.  This is how our brain thinks, this is how it works. This voices or internal dialogue is so normal that is probably that you can hear it while you are reading this post. It happened because language is actually verbal, and the writing is only the representation of a word.
The main idea I want to send is the importance of generating this internal dialogue. This mechanism is a very big opportunity for marketers because its influence in the decision-making process. Taking your prospect into a positive state will affect their purchase decisions in a good way. And you should use language in your favor to make that possible. For example instead of advertising “Without a security alarm, your family is at a risk”, you should say, “Sleep soundly in the safe knowledge that you have protected your home and family”.  Being in a positive state help to avoid buyer’s remorse, and increase repurchasing behavior. Buyer’s remorse is other way of Internal Talking that results of the contradiction between the UM and the CM in the purchase decision. Often we decide to buy stuff that we know we don’t need but we consciously decide to do it anyway.

Internal Dialogue to generate Trust

Other big use of Internal Dialogue in marketing is that it gives better results in gaining consumer’s trust.  It is much more efficient to let the consumer’s brain get or come out with the conclusion we want to state than sending the direct message. The main difference is the trust that we have to our brain vs the trust we have to the message transmitter. It could take weeks or month of efforts to become trustable to the consumer’s brain. But if we communicate “unconscious clues” to the consumer’s brain so it reveals the same message by its own, it is going to be much more comfortable and confident with the marketing message and it will probably turn into more committed decisions.

Timing in Decisions

The author explains that the UM works in a faster way than the CM, and of course with a quicker response. The importance comes from the knowledge that is possible for marketers to make prospects take decisions before they are consciously aware that the decision has been made. This is actually the result of “marketing to the unconscious mind”.

Also UM can take decisions without consulting the CM, and gives the marketer a window to work on.

To completely understand the timing in UM vs CM, the author include a real story about a Fireman Officer:

"A researcher tells the story of a firefighter in Cleveland who answered a routine call with his men. It was in the back of a one-and-a-half story house in a residential neighborhood in the kitchen.
The firefighters broke down the door, laid down their hose, and began dousing the fire with water. It should have abated, but it didn’t. As the fire lieutenant recalls, he suddenly thought to himself, “There’s something wrong here,” and he immediately ordered his men out.
Moments after they fled, the floor they had been standing on collapsed. The fire had been in the basement, not the kitchen as it appeared. When asked how he knew to get out, he could not explain it at all.
It took well over two hours of questioning for the fire lieutenant to piece together how he knew to get out. (First, the fire didn’t respond as it was supposed to; second, the fire was abnormally hot; third, it was quiet when it should have been noisier given the heat.)"

In this case, the smarter UM analyze tons of experiences of the lieutenant in just seconds to reach to the conclusion that there was a danger.

As a global conclusion we can say that the importance of UM exceeds marketing purposes but of course we could and should use them and take advantage to grow our businesses.

Why our brain love curves?

What do you think about this car?



It is often said that curvilinear shapes are more appeal to human being. It is based in some belief that we associate sharpness with danger and we get in a warning state, or also because we are surrounded with nature and all the curves within it makes us feel more comfortable in round spaces. Today we are going to analyze those beliefs and try to get them down-to-earth.

We are going to review the work of Vartanian (2013) about the impact in the brain when visualizing curves. It is actually well believed that curvature elicits pleasant emotions, but it is very difficult to measure.

To reach our goal, Vartanian ran some investigation using fMRI to understand what is happening in our brain in terms of activations when we are exposed to these types of curves and lines represented in the stimuli (in this case as architectural pictures).

From a strictly behavioral perspective, the first insight of the investigation is that the amount of curves was highly correlated with the beauty rating. 




Then the study consisted of presenting participants in a functional MRI (fMRI) scanner with photographs of interior spaces that varied in contour.

Neuroanatomically, the results demonstrated that judging the beauty of curvilinear spaces was associated exclusively with an increase in ACC activity over and above judging the beauty of rectilinear spaces. ACC is part of Brown et al.’s core circuit for aesthetic processing (Brown 2011 - Naturalizing aesthetics: Brain areas for aesthetic appraisal across sensory modalities), and its activation here is consistent with the wealth of behavioral data that point to the involvement of emotion and reward in preference for curved objects.

For the beauty judgment run, the contrast of curvilinear-rectilinear spaces revealed significant activation in ACC exclusively (Z = 3.54, x = –6, y = 42, z = –6, k = 11).



Conclusion

Beauty and curvilinear contour activated certain regions (ACC) that are strongly responsive to the reward properties and emotional salience of objects. So take that in mind when you are designing stuff for your business (from logos, products to even websites) to help yourself from a pure neuroscientifically point of view to improve the impact in your consumer.



As always, thanks for taking the time to read, any comment will be well received.

Does multitasking make us happy?

What makes you feel better, go running, meet friends, prepare nice dinner, finish your work and watch a movie, or just only focus in one activity, such as meeting your friends?

What give us more happiness, the joy of doing lots of things, or the satisfaction of doing only one but more accurate and in a better way?


The investigations from Jordan Etkin, Cassie Mogilner (2015) reached to the conclusion that  it depends on the amount of time we have to perform the activities we do enjoy more doing high variety of tasks or just focus in one activity. The measure of happiness was based on two questions: How happy do you feel right now? And how satisfied do you feel right now?

Shorter the time is, we prefer focus. Longer the time is, it gets all about diversity in the tasks.




So as we can see in the graphic, the threshold is in 1-hour-duration activities. So according to this investigation, if we have less than one hour, focusing in fewer tasks will give us more satisfaction. But in the other hand, more than 1 hour may be marginally you got more satisfaction by solving high variety of tasks.

It is all about the sensation of productivity.  More accomplished tasks in the same period of time makes people feel they are taking advantage of time. But nothing is free in life (isn’t it?), changing activities results in energy and cognitive resources spending. So people stress and loss productivity by switching their tasks. As conclusion, shorter periods just do not put up for the cost of changing so it is more efficient to focus in fewer tasks.

All of these insights are very important when it comes to organize the schedule. “Although repetition can make workers more productive in the short-term, the lack of stimulation eventually detracts from their happiness. So within an hour, tasks should be kept consistent to increase productivity, but across days, tasks should be varied to maintain stimulation and interest.”


Daniel Kahneman´s systems on decision making

Today we are going to discuss some important tools when it comes to analyzing human behaviors. We intend to state practical and clear examples that could be useful in everyday life. Although it has neuroscientific explanations we are not going to make use of them for the sake of the post.

TWO SYSTEMS

Let’s start with two experiments. First take a glance at the next image:


Here we can see how our automatic mode is activated and working. We can make some very accurate predictions on the image. The most important is that the man is angry. He is probably yelling to someone in the cellphone. Probably the language that he is using is not very polite. This comes to our mind automatically. And those involuntary responses, predictions, decisions is what Kahneman define as System 1.


Now let’s take another task, try to solve the next multiplication:


Here we can see how the other system works. The answer, although you can get it, won’t come directly to your mind. In order to get the exact result you need to make some effort and attention. This type of thinking is slow, and infer a sequence of steps.

SOME DEFINITIONS

This terms were originally proposed by the psychologists Keith Stanovich and Richard West, and will refer to two systems in the mind, System 1 and System 2.

INTERACTIONS BETWEEN SYSTEMS.

Both systems are active in normal conditions but each one tend to be more efficient in different situations. For example imagine that you are angry and want to yell someone that is annoying you, but it turns out to be your boss, what would the systems do?
System 1 is automatic, respond to emotions and works in an involuntary fast way, so it will yell but as the System 2 is aware of the possible consequences of yelling, so it takes control and stops you from making the very big mistake (here we are not judging the situation, in some occasions the correct thing to do is to yell, but this is a simple example). To do it, Systems 2 requires efforts and concentration.
Another simpler example could be the situation when you hear a powerful sound, it probably that unconsciously you turn around, and in order not to, you should make a conscious effort.
The same when you go to a restaurant an there is an exotic couple in the next table and you try to avoid staring.

THE LOW EFFORT RULE

As we said in the previous paragraph, each system is  more accurate in certain situations. Kahneman propose a rule of choice: our brain will follow the lowest effort way.
Daniel Kahneman investigated the use of mental energy that involved both process (Systems 1 and 2). He reached to the conclusion that System 2 requires much more energy and effort. That could explain why when is possible our brain chose the System 1 as it works in a faster, effortless way, and usually predict very accurate in easy situations. But not always it is the best choice, and as we saw in the previous examples when it was necessary, it tells System 2 to take charge in the decision making.


I hope you like this approach to Kahneman’s Systems and hope these one become new tools that help you analyze people behavior.

Why is so important to remember?

Remembering is essential for our living. Can you imagine having to learn to walk every single day? 
Can you picture yourself forgetting where the bathroom at your place is every time you woke up?

There is still so much to learn in this field but we are going to describe some approaches and important facts on Memory and Learning for business and marketers.

Just to introduce you with a smile into the memory issues, some funny facts of 50 First Dates,


Types of memory

In order to start this post I wouold like to show a brief chart that include the different types of the memories and the duration of them.


Within the Long-term memory we can find a very important distinction:

  • Declarative: is in charge of remembering facts or events.
  • Non-Declarative: works in a deeper awareness level. It is retrieved without conscious or control. For example: riding a bike or reading this post.


The most important conclusion I want to take from the previous distinction is the importance of the non-conscious memory. It drives almost all our behavior, and altought it is still a lot to learn, most researchers are working on it. Because once we can understand what people really like, (in this case, related to memory, as we will see in the next paragraph in the Coca-Cola vs Pepsi Experiment) we will be able to deliver it rising the value for the consumer and embracing our brands above the competition.

How to measure in a pretty simple way?

We can ask people how they remember a brand or even how they believe they know it.

  • TOM: Top Of Mind, it ranks the brands in the order from the most known to the least. There are lots of variants in this method, but essentially they answer the question, “do you know this brand?"
  • Subjective Knowledge: This measure allows the researcher or marketer to understand how the consumer believes to understand or know the brand.
  • Association: It approaches to the question, “Do you feel our brand to be Positive or Negative?”

NeuroMarketing approach using fMRI

There is an interesting research provided by Sam McCloy on how memory and past experience affects preference.

Coca-Cola vs Pepsi Experiment

The experiment consist in two parts. First a blind test and then another one where the consumer know the brand he is drinking.
Blind test had no strong results (besides people often think they can differentiate Coca-Cola and Pepsi), but when people knew they were drinking Coca-Cola most of them actually prefered it.

As we can see, there is change on preference just by knowing what are we drinking, and according to the study it is related to the remembering of past experience where having a Coke was more rewarding (thank you very much for messing with my mind Coca-Cola Marketing Team… ).

To state all this Neuromarketing hipothesis, we can see in the fMRI results the difference between the blind test and the Coca-Cola test.

The main conclusions were that during the blind test people feel more appealing the Pepsi due to the activation in the Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex, that is actually a “reward center” area.
But when the consumer knew what he was drinking, the activation area change. Only when the consumer drink Coke, the scan showed strong activation in the Hippocampus and in the DLPF which are "center for memory and emotions". So besides people actually liked Pepsi, they were more inclined to chose Coke based on the memory of past experience and emotional connections.

As always, thanks for taking the time to read.
Hope you enjoy!


Bibliography:

Neural Correlates of Behavioral Preference for Culturally Familiar Drinks, Sam McClure(2004)
An Introduction to Consumer Neuroscience & Neuromarketing, Thomas Zoega Ramsoy(2014)

Attention, Attention Please!!

What is the attention?

In order to make it easier to read and actually don’t lose your attention we are going to focus directly in the first and the second aspects of attention.


1 - Bottom-up

This type of attention is a rapid, automatic form of selective attention that depends on the intrinsic properties of the input, such as its color or intensity (Koch 2004). Also it works with brightness and movement. It is also known as saliency-based attention, indicating that the more salient an object, the higher the probability of it being noticed.

The main idea is automation, it means that most of the times you can’t control it. And in case you want not to pay attention you even have to focus on it.


It can be seen as a pre-attention




2 - Top-Down Control

Top-down control depends on internal and external states, goals, and expectations. Hence, looking  for a can of Coke will enhance processing of red areas in visual input by increasing the neuronal sensitivity for that particular color (Theeuwes, 2010; Treisman & Gelade, 1980; Van der Lans, Pieters, & Wedel, 2008)
The main idea is that the information that is relevant for goal attainment will be attended to more than irrelevant  information. For example, when we are thirsty, we pay more attention to drinks than to other ítems.

It can be seen as focal-attention.

Just to finish, here we have a funny example of focal-attention. 







What about attention on Marketing?

It is especially important to drag the attention (because it is highly correlated with 'buy intention') of customer in Retail. We can take advantages of the attention tips in order to organize the shelfs and as well the 'shopping trip'. 

For example, we can say that product which drag top-down control attention should be at the back of the store so you force the your potencial customer to go through all the supermarket and visualize other product via bottom-up attention. 



Thanks for your time!
Hope you can enjoy!



Changes on purpose

Changes are common in this “modern time”. From X-gen to Y-Gen, Millennials to Generation Z, isolated business to big economics blocks, changes are everywhere and in every magnitude. Time changes everything and “Purpose of the business” is not foreign to this trend.



My personal view of Purpose is that it has change during last decades, and even today is continuously evolving. I find two distinctive moments, first one when the purpose was personal benefit and the benefit for the society was pursuit if possible, and second one, the modern view of purpose, which goes after the benefit of the whole society, the need to make this world a better place and as consequence achieve the personal benefit.

After thinking on this topic I came to the conclusion that these changes are generated due to changes in the society. As society is the only cluster that aggregates all the consumer and prospects of all the companies of the world, changes in this group will impact in all of them. The change we can appreciate is that people has been becoming more concern on well-being, on greater benefits and on trying to make a better world for everyone. We can prove it from different point of view depending on the group of interest; as an example we can say that taking care of environment is making a better place, or also the inclusion of minorities could impact on major benefit for those societies. But as we see they are all ways of making greater good for all of us.

As an example I would like to quote P&G Purpose: 


“We will provide branded products and services of superior quality and value that improve the lives of the world’s consumers, now and for generations to come. As a result, consumers will reward us with leadership sales, profit and value creation, allowing our people, our shareholders and the communities in which we live and work to prosper.”

Where we can see exposed the benefit for the today’s and next generations’ consumers (what we can call “society benefit”) and also the benefit of the shareholders (what we can call “personal benefit”) that comes as results of the previous one.

Experiencing Self vs Remembering Self Daniel Kahneman point of view

Why is different the feeling of the experience vs the memory of the feeling? Which one is more important for our choice decision path?


According to Daniel Kahneman we have two selves. One of them is the experiencing self that is the one that lives in the present, the one that feels. On the other hand, we have the remembering self, which is the one that store the story of your life. Let’s give an easy example to understand how this works (Example provide by D.Kahneman).

Colonoscopy test among the 2 systems.


The example provided is from the time when it was painfully to have a colonoscopy. On the next graph you can see two different colonoscopies.

The first doctor performed a shorter colonoscopy (9 minutes) but it stop in the most painful part. The second continue with the colonoscopy so it is longer but it finishes in a lower level of pain.



So here are some interesting questions to think:

Who is the patient that suffers the most? Which surgeon would you choose in your next colonoscopy?

Here we have to differentiate the two systems, the system 1 (Experiencing self) would say that the Patient B felt more aggregated pain (it was a longer operation with the same peaks of pain).

The interesting thing to understand is that for the system 2 (Remembering self) the story is a little bit different. For system 2, time is not very important, so the extra-time would not affect the measure of the pain in this systems. But the fact that the last moment of the surgery on Patient A is on the highest level of pain will store the event as a worse memory than the surgery perform to Patient B. This is very important to answer the second question, because in order to make new decisions we reach our past experience to decide, so its probably that although Patient B suffers more he had a better remembering of the experience and he is going to choose surgeon 2 in case of a new colonoscopy.

So what do you think is more important in a brand/product experience, the experience itself or the remembering of the experience? 

Since I heard Daniel Kahneman I start to analyze regular daily situations and how we remember them. For example when you go to a restaurant, what would happened if they charge you before you eat. Probably your memories wouldn't be about paying but about having the great dinner. Or maybe if after you pay the restaurant give you candy on your way out? Will these enhance the experience and make your "remembering self" to choose you again? There are a lot of factors among the decision making process but these are strategies that I probably would use to increase my results in any business.


Here is the complete lecture of D.Kahneman


As always, thanks for taking the time for reading.

Any comment will be well received.

Mirror Neurons. Understanding other’s emotions via internal simulation.


What are the Mirror Neurons?

Mirror neurons (Rizzolatti, G.) Hypothesis: “Mirror neurons” transforms sensory information describing actions of others into a motor format similar to that the observers internally generate when they imagine themselves doing that action or when they actually perform it. That is the book definition, but to make it easy, we can say that mirror neurons activate our brain in a similar way that the brain activation that have had the others that actually is feeling the emotion. In some way, it could be related to empathy. This process is done as an internal simulation of the looked emotion. But it comes up the question if we able to recognize the feelings of other due to their facial expressions.

Do we recognize expressions? Is this a learned or an innate competence?

It is pretty normal to recognize the fundamental expression such us happiness, sadness, anger, boredom. But how do we understand them? First let’s see some funny fact about a learnt behavior of our brain that tends to feel comfortable with the objects they see all the time. Specially our faces since this is one of the things in which we spent most of our time seeing (remember we are social animal and we live in community).


Let's try to understand some brain behavior using an interesting example: please check the two photos. Then click on the second (the rotated one).



Now we can see how confortable we feel with the mouth and the eyes not being rotated, and that is because our brain realize they are in the way they should be, even though most of us do not have a clue.

Here is another example.

Question: which one is the depression of the surface and which one is the elevation of the surface?



The answer is that they are the same picture but rotated, but why we perceive the first as the hole and the second as a hill? That is because to adaptation and learning that the light comes from above of us we tend to make that guess. But image if the light comes from the inside? Probably we would in reverse. So these examples could say that we learn from our experience and for example when we see “happy” people we can learn from the facial expressions and then understand them in other situations. As a matter of fact, this is NOT TRUE. There is a great study done on blind people where they compare facial expressions on athletes that have been blind since they were born so it was impossible for them to learn the facial expressions, and in fact the expressions correlates almost perfectly between them showing that fundamental emotions are INNATE.

Marketing applications

This is very important to communication, for example in print media. Because maybe you can use mirror neurons to induce behavior in your consumers. Just as an example we can see: STRENGTH? EMPOWERMENT? Try it yourself with different campaigns an try to figure it out what emotions is trying to emphasize with.

As always, thanks for taking the time to read. Any comment will be well received.

Bibliography


  1. psychcentral.com/news/2008/12/30/facial-expressions-are-innate-not-learned/3570.html 
  2. http://www.unipr.it/arpa/mirror/english/staff/rizzolat.htm

Pavlovian Conditioning can help us to educate our consumers?

In this article I would like to talk a little bit about some learnings I got from my Neuroscience courses. I find this topic really interesting due to the applications in marketing. 

In this case we are going to see how Sheldon uses it to educate Penny in order to avoid her bad behavior (from Sheldon’s point of view)




First we are going to define two situations in order to make the explanation easier: 

Neutral situation:
  • Unconditional Stimulus: Eating chocolate
  • Unconditional Response: Feeling good/ Having some pleasure (in this case provide by chocolate)
Conditioning situation:
  • Conditional Stimulus: If she behave she get some chocolate
  • Conditional Response: She just behaves and feels good about it without needing the positive reinforcement of the chocolate (that’s when Penny gets fully trained.)
The idea is to associate the response of the neutral situation with the conditioning one by repeating the conditioning stimulus very times till the brain adapts to having the good sensation after behaving well (despite the satisfaction is provide by the chocolate, we educate the brain to think that is provide by the action of well behavior). So then a good behavior provides a good feeling.


Neuroscience point of view


Let's take this to the next level.

There is a part of our brain that reacts to rewards (actually expected rewards as you will see). If we measure this single-cell activity we can know when this part activate and relate it with the different moments of the exercise.



Now we can see that the two moments and the brain activation. The first moment is the sound stimulus and the second is the reward. We can see the chronology as long as the experiment gets repeated. And we can see how the brain activation (that is when most of the points get closer horizontally) changes from the reward moment to the conditioned stimulus sound as the experiment goes on proving that the dog actually get excited by the expected reward.

This became amazing when you think about your consumers, because it happens the exact same. Let’s talk about some examples from Coca-Cola. It has been proven that the best moment, I mean the peak of pleasure about drinking a Coke is the exact previous millisecond of drinking, because all your brain is fully expecting the moment and imagine the best Coke ever. And that’s not a coincidence. You have been taught by Coca-Cola (and many other big brands) to have a responsive behavior to their products. 


So you have to be very careful when you execute your brand campaigns because every time you talk to your consumers you are telling them how to feel about your products. And that will take part on the decision process and could make the difference in the consumers’ choice.

Thanks for your time!

Any comment will be well received.


Consumers “Deep Insights”, do they change over time?

When we analyze our consumers, every Researcher or Marketer dreams about finding the Insight that will allow their Brand to differentiate and if it is well executed would increase exponentially their sales. But are our key findings perdurable in time?

As kick off I would like you to see Chandlers Bing New Computer Video:


His brand new computer has 12 MB of RAM and 500MB of Hard Disk, and he use it for games and stuff. And we start thinking, what would we say today with computers of more 32 GB ( 32000 MB; It is 2666X times Chandler’s Computer) and hard drives in around Terabytes, but we keep on using it for having fun. So what I want to reach the conclusion that the true insight has no change and it is: PEOPLE LIKE TO HAVE FUN. 


Yes we know that we did not discorver dynamite but it is important to recall it, because even time passes and people change, true deep insights will remain.





I always remember a quote from a very important member from my job in P&G: "The deeper the Insights is, the more universal it becames. People is like an onion and our true insights are in the inner layers". That's why we can apply them for a wider target or segment. But despite the good it looks like, those insights are the most difficult to discover. Thats the main reason of why better insights are (some times) discovered when you look in consumer that is not your average. Because all the uncertainity allows us an easier way to reach their inner thoughts and from the understanding of their behaviour we can develop very valuable insights.

Thank you very much for your time! I hope you enjoy.
Any comment will be well receive. 

What is Dan Ariely’s Self-Herding and Long Terms effects of initial decisions?

What is Self-Herding?

Self-Herding is “our tendency to follow the same decisions we have made in the past (future decision are influenced by previous decisions).”

What about following the herd?

As an example to picture the idea we can imagine two exact restaurants. Restaurant A and Restaurant B, both have the same menu, same prices, etc. So imagine one person came, and chose one of them. He has not any previous information about them, so he chooses Restaurant B. Then other person arrives, and sees Restaurant A with zero people and Restaurant B with one person. Which would you think he would choose? He would choose Restaurant B, because he may think it is better because the first person is there. And so on people will continue arriving and Restaurant B is a hit and Restaurant A is a failure, where everything was a consequence of the initial decision.
But this is not a rational decision, it comes from our instincts. For a better understanding, there is another example about Exit doors. What would make you choose an Exit door? Imagine you are in a mall and there is a fire. You see all people running in one direction. Are you going to say, “Ok, maybe there is another way out, I should run the exact other way..?” NOO! People always follow the herd. We don't like to make decisions. As easiest as possible is the way, we are going to take it. 

“We remember our actions but we don’t remember why.”

There is another beautiful example provided by Dan and also my favorite one. And please remember this first sentence.

Starbucks Coffee or Dunkin’ Donuts Coffee?




As a kick-off question, please take some seconds to try this: How much would you pay for a coffee? How do you get to that conclusion?

Rational Theory explains that we internally make a trade-off between the value that coffee adds to ourselves vs its cost. If its value is more that its cost, we buy. Otherwise, we don’t.

It looks really coherent, but here we are going to try a different approach. Let´s say we always get a coffee before going to work in Dunkin’ Donuts for $0.40. Same routine every day. But one day we go out early from work, and we are thirsty, so thirsty and tired that we need a coffee imperatively. We run into a Starbucks (with no previous information about it) and we decide to buy. But when we look at the prices, the coffee costs $2.40. The Dunkin Donuts was far, so the cost was higher also, and we really need that coffee. So we buy. What happened next? Next time we run into Starbucks to buy a coffee our mind does not remember the emotional transient from the other time, it doesn’t remember how thirsty we were or how tired or wherever. It just reminds that we bought. So necessarily it should have been a good deal. And then, we repurchased coffee in Starbucks. This mind process keeps on and on defining what Dan calls Self-Herding Path. And when time goes on, we remember less our first emotional state and our bought become less judgmental.


But then, why Dunkin Donuts first decision does not impact on Starbucks? The main reason is the effort that Starbucks have been doing to appear as a different category. People’s mind tends to compare within category. For example when you go to a restaurant and you look at wine’s prices, do you compare with how much milk could you buy with that money? NO! You just check the prices between the wines. This is the same. Starbucks do not have donuts,  it have croissants. It do not have simple coffee, it have macchiato, cappuccino, etc... So people’s mind does not tend to compare.
Those are some examples the long lasting effects of initial decisions, and we can see how irrationality behaviors impact ourselves in daily basis.

Dan Ariely (born April 29, 1967) is an Israeli American professor of psychology and behavioral economics. He teaches at Duke University and is the founder of The Center for Advanced Hindsight and also the co-founder of BEworks. Ariely's talks on TED have been watched over 4.8 million times. He is the author of Predictably Irrational and The Upside of Irrationality, both of which became New York Times best sellers, as well as The Honest Truth about Dishonesty

Thanks for taking the time to read! Hope you have enjoy!



Negociación Inteligente Parte 1

Esta es la parte 1 de los 3 de los artículos donde repasaremos algunas técnicas de negociación propuestas en el manual: Getting the Yes el cual considero un libre Must Read para todos. 

Partiendo de la base que las discusiones del día a día generalmente yacen en la diferencia de posiciones que las personas tienen sobre diversos temas, y mas allá de mi fanatismo por las negociaciones, creo que este libro ayudaría a solucionar muchisimos problemas, ya que abre un espacio de charla donde se ataca principalmente a dichas posiciones enfocandose en lograr los intereses de ambas partes.


Introducción:

Vamos a introducir al lector con algunos terminos que encontrara familiares debido a que se hallara identificado en su vida personal.

Vamos a definir 3 tipos de negociadores:

Negociador Duro: Este es el que toma posiciones extremas, aspira a ganar sin importar como. Usualmente lastima a las relaciones.

Negociador Suave: Este es el que prioriza las relaciones. Acepta dar concesiones con el objetivo de evitar conflictos. Busca soluciones amistosas y usualmente se siente explotado y amargado.

NEGOCIACIÓN POR INTERESES
Negociador por principios: Este aspira a entender a la otra parte, sus intereses y conseguir el mejor acuerdo que ambas partes saquen ventaja. Este tipo de negociacion es la que vamos a describir a lo largo de los articulos.
NEGOCIACIÓN POR POSICIÓN
CONCESIÓN EXTREMA

Review Parte I: El Problema

No negocie en base a posiciones. Esta es la forma de negociar mas común. La partes solo se dedican a tomar posiciones, ejercer presión y luego abandonar, así generando solo una serie de posiciones distintas hasta el acuerdo o que se rompa la negociación.

La forma ideal de negociación, muy alejada de la anterior, la vamos a definir según:
"Cualquier método de negociación debe juzgarse conforme a tres criterios: debe conducir a un acuerdo sensato si el acuerdo es posible. Debe ser eficiente. Y debe mejorar, o por lo menos no deteriorar la relación entre las partes. (Un acuerdo sensato puede definirse como aquel que satisface los intereses legítimos de ambas partes dentro de lo posible, que resuelve los conflictos de intereses con equidad, que es durable, y que tiene en cuenta los intereses de la comunidad.)"
Un tema a tener cuidado es que cuanta mayor atención y preocupación se tiene por las posiciones, menos se piensa en los interés propios y ajenos, de manera que el acuerdo se hace mas difícil. Ademas este tipo de discusión es insensato e ineficiente, sin olvidar del grave peligro que corre la relación entre las partes.

Ser amable no es la solución. Mas allá de este proceso ser eficiente y prudente para la relación, puede ser trágico a la hora de buscar resultados debido a acuerdos desequilibrados.

El juego equilibrado es ser suave y amistoso con las personas pero duro con el problema. 

Dicho esto definimos a los objetos de la negociación de la siguiente manera. Por un lado lo sustancial y por otro lado a la relación. Muchas veces la relación tiene a confundirse con el problema tanto que se empieza a tratar a la persona y al problema como si fueran uno solo. Para ejemplificar, puede mencionarse "la cocina es un desastre" y automáticamente la gente lo lee como un ataque y no como una observación. Este error es típico de la negociación sobre posiciones y para evitarlo se debe atacar el problema según la negociación por principios que ejecuta acciones tanto sobre intereses como sobre la relación. 

En las próximas semanas estaré finalizando los demás artículos donde seguiremos revisando estos interesantes principios de negociación.

Como siempre, muchas gracias por su tiempo.

Cualquier tema, no dude en comentar.



Cluster Analysis con Latent Class Analysis

Presentacion de métodos de Cluster Analysis con Latent Class Analysis 


A continuación intentaremos introducir al lector en nuevos y sofisticados metodos de análisis de cluster.

A modo de introducción definiremos algunos términos necesarios para la posterior comprensión,

Caso: Variables manifiestas sobre las cuales se va a llevar el análisis. Se definen en forma de vectores. Por ejemplo, los resultados de una encuesta o los rasgos de un tipo de consumidor de un FMCG.

Clustering: Herramienta para agrupar casos según un criterio especifco, donde generalmente, los vectores de un mismo grupo (o clústers) comparten propiedades comunes. El conocimiento de los grupos puede permitir una descripción sintética de un conjunto de datos multidimensionales complejo.

Matriz Distancias: Es una matriz que tiene en sus componentes las distancias entre los coeficientes correspondientes. 

Clase Latente: Son variables que no son directamente observables pero si pueden ser inferidas a partir de variables que si son medibles. Un ejemplo de este tipo de variable seria la “Inseguridad” que no se puede medir, pero si se puede inferir (por ejemplo) en función la cantidad de robos de la zona.


Los métodos clásicos usados por la mayoría de los practicionistas son el “Hierarchical Clustering” y el "K-Means Clustering" (o “Non-Hierarchical Clustering”). Estos métodos son sencillos, fáciles de aprender y fáciles de aplicar. Pero como contra tiene grandes limitaciones, entre ellas podemos nombrar,
  • No permite trabajar con datos Binarios o Nominales (salvo que se utilice la medida de Gou, pero no hay consenso en su uso).
  • Asigna de forma absoluta los casos a cada cluster.
  • Es puramente matemático (sin tener en cuenta las herramientas estadísticas)

Ahora adentremos un poco en la metodologia que aplica el Clustering LCA. A grandes rasgos, lo que hace esta herramienta es tratar de asignar a cada Caso una probabilidad de pertenecer a una Clase Latente (luego comentaremos cuales son los métodos para definirlas), de modo que queda definido un grupo de Casos dentro de cada Clase los cuales se espera que sean lo más homogéneos entre si. De esta manera lo que se hace es definir una especie de regresión para las Clases y debido a esto se va a poder ingresar como input tanto a variables continuas como nominales. Debido a el uso del LCA tambien se pueden aplicar técnicas estadísticas altamente validadas y ademas se evita la asignación absoluta de pertenencia a un cluster de modo que se puede entender los grises entre los casos propuestos.

¿Cómo determinar la cantidad de Clases?

Para esto vamos a utilizar AIC (Akaike Information Criterion) o el  BIC (Bayesian Information Criterion), de los cuales para muestras relativamente grandes usaremos el BIC. Usualmente se presentan mediante un gráfico en función de la cantidad de Clases. Con esto definimos dicha cantidad de clases, la cual será la que minimice el criterio elegido.

¿Cómo definir cada clase?

Para completar el análisis se debe poner el "label" a cada clase. Para ello vamos a tener que analizar detenidamente las variables sobre las cuales se realizo el análisis y de forma agrupada entender sus relaciones con las clases a partir de las probabilidades condicionales de pertenecer a dicha clase. Este análisis es muy rico a la hora de hacer uso de esta herramienta para la investigación de las relaciones entre los clusters.

¿Qué software debo usar?

Para llevar adelante el análisis, se debe recurrir a distintos software. Este párrafo en  uno de los mas importantes de esta presentación ya que voy a mencionar de forma clara sobre que programas trabajar. Primero y principal se debe entender que el software seleccionado va a depender en gran medida de quien es el usuario, y de los objetivos del análisis. Los mas importantes son Latent Gold, MCLUST y el poLCA. El primero es el único de los tres que requiere el pago de una licencia para su uso, mientras que los últimos dos son de código abierto ya que corresponden a paquetes desarrollados sobre R, (http://cran.r-project.org/). 



A modo de cierre voy a dejar bibliografía donde se puede encontrar un análisis completo y los links al software mencionados:

El procedimiento para su estimación y calculo lo recomiendo buscar en:



Como siempre, MUCHAS GRACIAS POR SU TIEMPO.

Cualquier tema no dude en comentar.